handcrafted in New York
Custom decorated sugar cookies for every milestone — weddings, birthdays, corporate events, and beyond.
Hand-Decorated
Every cookie is an original
NYC Made
Baked fresh in New York
Any Occasion
Weddings to birthdays
Our story
Where artistry meets flavor — every cookie is baked with intention and decorated with love.
Recent Creations
The Beginning
Lizzie discovered her love of baking growing up in Cincinnati, Ohio, and carried that passion through her years at the University of Michigan. After graduating, she put her baking dreams on hold to pursue a career in investment banking in New York City — but the oven was never far from her heart. After a few years of focusing on her career and life in the Big Apple, Lizzie has slowly started to return to what she loves most, channeling her creativity into precisely decorated cookies and one-of-a-kind designs.
Every cookie is made from scratch using time-honored recipes, then hand-decorated with meticulous detail. No two sets are ever exactly alike.
What we stand for
Each design is sketched, planned, and executed with the same care a painter brings to a canvas.
Only the finest butter, flour, and pure extracts. No artificial shortcuts — ever.
Every order is personal. Lizzie works directly with each client to bring their vision to life.
Ready to order
Coming Soon
Something sweet is on its way. In the meantime, place a custom order directly with Lizzie.
The work
Check out some of my past work! Click each photo below for more images in that category.
@cookiesbylizzie
Follow along on Instagram for daily drops, behind-the-scenes, and new designs.
Follow on InstagramMade for you
Every order starts with a conversation. Tell Lizzie what you're dreaming of — she'll take it from there.
Standard
Elaborate / Logo
Mini Cookies
How it works
Fill out the form below with your event details and vision.
Lizzie will send you a custom design proof for approval.
Your cookies are made fresh to order with care and precision.
Pick up in NYC or ship nationwide. Gift-ready packaging always.
Fill out the form and Lizzie will respond within 48 hours.
✨ Thank you! Lizzie will be in touch within 48 hours.
What clients say
Every review means the world. Here's what some of our favorite clients have shared.
"So thankful for Lizzie and her cookie-decorating skills 💓 Lizzie created 2-dozen fun and cheerful cookies for my sisters Bachelorette Party."
Bailey B.
Bachelorette Party
"Lizzie did an amazing job on my sisters graduations cookies! They were not only delicious, but super cute!"
Samantha M.
Graduation
"Lizzie was able to make some cookies for a bridal shower I hosted in 8 days notice and boy were they good and beautiful!!"
Kate K.
Bridal Shower
"I want to post how beautiful and delicious these Cookies by Lizzie were! Her prices are extremely reasonable."
Hannah M.
Custom Order
"Thank you so much Lizzie! These were for a Couples bar shower I hosted! They turned out amazing and so DELICIOUS!"
Krissy S.
Couples Shower
"Ordered these super cute cookies for my mom for Nurse's Appreciation Week! She loved them and they were delicious."
Karley F.
Nurse's Appreciation
"Lizzie's cookies are delicious works of art! We ordered her cookies to have as favors at our elementary school's 8th grade dance."
Jennifer D.
School Event
"Beautiful cookies for a bachelorette party. They were also delicious & packaged nicely. She exceeded my expectations."
Lindsey R.
Bachelorette Party
"Lizzie completely got what we were going for, merging elements to create a custom tray that delighted the graduate."
Lisa W.
Graduation
"We had so much fun decorating cookies! It was very easy to get started and the cookies were very tasty, too!"
Lauren K.
Cookie Decorating
Share your experience
Enjoyed your Cookies by Lizzie order? We'd love to hear about it — your review means everything to us.
Thank you so much!
Your review has been sent to Lizzie. It truly means the world. 🍪
Your selection
Nothing here yet
Head to the Shop to pick your cookies.
Final pricing is confirmed when Lizzie responds. Prices are per dozen unless noted.
✨ Your request is on its way! Lizzie will be in touch within 48 hours.